PDA

View Full Version : April 1865


KCBOOMER
04-15-2003, 10:43 AM
They ran this last night on the History Channel and it was fabulous. The show focuses on the events in April 1865 that bring the Civil War to a close and particularly focuses on the actions of Lincoln, Grant, Sherman, Lee, and Longstreet. Obviously the story mentions numerous other historical figures as well.

As a Civil War aficionado I always am amazed at the compassion and respect Lincoln, Grant and Sherman had for their Souther brethren. The surrender terms they offered the surrendering rebels are probably the most generous in history. It should be noted that no leading figure of the Confederacy was executed for his activities, though in Jeff Davis's case it was a near run thing. Grant personally intervened when the hawks wanted to try Lee.

The wisdom of Lee and Johnston to stand four square against the Civil War becoming a guerrilla war as some wanted to do. Lee in particular wanted the South to accept it had lost and to come together with their Northern brethren.

I simply cannot listen, read, or watch a re-enactment, of the surrender of Lee's Army with a dry eye. The respect that Gen. Chamberlain, who was designated as the officer to accept the surrender of the Army of Northern Virginia, showed to the ANV by having his men come to "shoulder arms" is unbelievably compelling.

As compelling in a much smaller venue, was shortly after the war in a church in either Richmond or Arlington an elderly black man went to the communion rail in a white church. The pastor and congregation was stunned and couldn't move until until a grey haired, somewhat elderly white man, walked up to the railing to receive communion beside the black man. Communion then proceeded. The white gentleman, was, of course, Robert E. Lee.

The show does not attempt to re-fight the Civil War. It simply focuses on the events of April 1865. Highly recommended.

WiredTiger
04-15-2003, 11:22 AM
I'll have to try to catch that the next time it comes around. I find the Civil War a very interesting time in our history. I have quite abit about the war and what lead the country to that conflict.

What strikes me is that the Founding Fathers knew that they had a problem on their hands but for the sake of the new country put off the arguement for later. The even had rules that the slavery issue could not be brought up in Congress for a certain number of years.

I also was amazed that a lot of the leaders from the North and the South had gone to school together and fought together. I don't think I ever really got the sense that this was true in school.

I would recommend both "Confederates in the Attic" By Tony Horowitz and "Don't Know Much About The Civil War" by Kenneth Davis. Both excellent books.

TimmyB
04-15-2003, 12:30 PM
Caught most of it last night.

It never fails to amaze me how many things could have gone so terribly wrong that month that would have had such negative impact on the nation.

While the Radical Republicans tried to make Reconstruction a more vindictive affair, the tone set by Lincoln, Grant, Sherman, Chamberlain, Lee and Longstreet in those key days took the steam out of the RR's before they could get started. Yes, the next 10 years were not the most admirable in our history, but they would have been far worse if not for the compassion and wisdom of Lincoln and those five fighting men.

Even in his death Lincoln was able to cast a shadow over Reconstruction which probably saved the country from splitting in two again.

pathogan
04-16-2003, 08:47 AM
...i had trouble with is the ongoing hagiography of RELee...Chamberlain is probably my favorite character in american history.Grant is finally getting the historical recognition he deserves,not as the drunk next to the "gentlemanly" Lee,but as a superior military commander and conciliator...a terrific show

Skip
04-16-2003, 11:00 AM
Haven't seen the show, but I totally agree with everything pathogan said above. Amen.

nyy26wc
04-16-2003, 09:22 PM
I taped it, but haven't had a chance to see it.

Let's see, tomorrow the Yankees have a day game. So, I've got the tape of that one, plus the tape of tonight's West Wing and Law & Order (even though I've already seen both of those episodes) scheduled for tomorrow night.

pwdennis
04-17-2003, 05:20 PM
The History Channel usually puts on first class productions. It may be the most worthwhile channel currently broadcasting

nyy26wc
04-18-2003, 12:11 AM
I watched the tape tonight and it was another excellent job by the History Channel.

Has anyone read the book it came from?