NDF Contest Voting - 1st Basemen

[Duque]

This thread is specifically for voting on the 1st Basemen. Remember, contestants are to rank the players 1-12, with 1 being the highest, and 12 the lowest. Contestants are not to vote for their own players.

Reminder - the voting process is entirely subjective. All votes are due by Sunday, 1/27/02.

Here are the 1st Basemen:

Keith Hernandez
Eddie Murray
Johnny Mize
Willie Stargell
George Sisler
Hank Greenberg
Bill Terry
Willie McCovey
Jimmie Foxx
Jeff Bagwell
Will Clark
Lou Gehrig
Rafael Palmeiro

[Xanadu Dragon]

Here's my vote - -- -

1. Jimmie Foxx
2. Johnny Mize
3. Lou Gehrig
4. Eddie Murray
5. Willie McCovey
6. Hank Greenberg
7. Will Clark
8. Jeff Bagwell
9. Willie Stargell
10. Bill Terry
11. George Sisler
12. Keith Hernandez

[Throwback]

Here's My Vote

1. Lou Gehrig
2. Jimmie Foxx
3. George Sisler
4. Johnny Mize
5. Willie Stargell
6. Bill Terry
7. Jeff Bagwell
8. Willie McCovey
9. Will Clark
10. Rafael Palmeiro
11. Eddie Murray
12. Keith Hernandez

[Duque]

My lineup:

1. Lou Gehrig
2. Jimmie Foxx
3. Johnny Mize
4. Hank Greenberg
5. Eddie Murray
6. Jeff Bagwell
7. Willie McCovey
8. Willie Stargell
9. Rafael Palmeiro
10. Will Clark
11. George Sisler
12. Keith Hernandez

[Golden Bear]

Lou Gehrig
Hank Greenberg
Johnny Mize
Eddie Murray
Willie McCovey
Willie Stargell
George Sisler
Jeff Bagwell
Bill Terry
Rafael Palmeiro
Keith Hernandez
Will Clark

[ChrisCary]

Don Mattingly


Gehrig
Foxx
Greenberg
Mize
McCovey
Murray
Palmiero
Terry
Bagwell
Hernandez

[Duque]

Chris - no Will Clark or Stargell?

[Yogi#8Fan]

Here's my :2cents: worth(less):

1. Lou Gehrig
2. Jimmie Foxx
3. Johnny Mize
4. Hank Greenberg
5. Eddie Murray
6. Willie Stargell
7. George Sisler
8. Rafael Palmeiro
9. Jeff Bagwell
10. Bill Terry
11. Keith Hernandez
12. Will Clark

[pjl7]

Gehrig
Foxx
McCovey
Murray
Stargell
Greenberg
Sisler
Mize
Bagwell
Terry
Palmiero
Hernandez

[BuzzBuzzard]

Gehrig
Foxx
McCovey
Mize
Hernandez
Murray
Stargell
Greenberg
Palmeiro
Terry
Sisler
Clark

[b-ball-lunachik]

It still just becomes a big blur...

1. Gehrig
2. Foxx
3. Greenberg
4. Murray
5. Stargell
6. McCovey
7. Sisler
8. Bagwell
9. Palmeiro
10. Hernandez
11. Terry
12. Clark

[nyy26wc]

1) Jimmie Foxx
2) Willie McCovey
3) Jeff Bagwell
4) Willie Stargell
5) Johnny Mize
6) Hank Greenberg
7) Rafael Palmeiro
8) Eddie Murray
9) Bill Terry
10) George Sisler
11) Will Clark
12) Keith Hernandez

[hmrsf]

1. Gehrig
2. Foxx
3. Mize
4. Stargel
5. Greenberg
6. McCovey
7. Palmeiro
8. Clark
9. Hernandez
10. Sisler
11. Bagwell
12. Terry

[Duque]

11 in - any chance of getting 13?

Reminder: If you miss a ballot, a 1st place vote (12 points) will be subtracted from your player's final total.

[Xanadu Dragon]

Originally posted by Duque
11 in - any chance of getting 13?

Reminder: If you miss a ballot, a 1st place vote (12 points) will be subtracted from your player's final total.

Duque - - will we be doing this retro on the pitcher and catcher vote? If not, is it really fair?

I believe we had one miss on the pitchers and two on the catchers, no?

[BuzzBuzzard]

Well, it was Mex who missed twice (3 times if you count 1B) and I can tell you with almost 100% certainty, she will not vote at all.

[Duque]

Originally posted by Xanadu Dragon


Duque - - will we be doing this retro on the pitcher and catcher vote? If not, is it really fair?

I believe we had one miss on the pitchers and two on the catchers, no?

I could certainly do that - right now, if people are missing votes several times, it penalizes the people who do vote.

Edit: Okay, I went back and recalculated everything. You'll find the updated tally at the end of the Catchers voting thread.

[redsox617]

1. Gehrig
2. Foxx
3. Mize
4. Murray
5. Greenberg
6. McCovey
7. Palmeiro
8. Clark
9. Hernandez
10. Sisler
11. Bagwell
12. Terry

[Duque]

Did hmrsf and rs617 share notes? Their ballots are almost identical! ;)

And, the final results for the 1st Basemen are:

1. Lou Gehrig (nyy26wc) - 130 total points
2. Jimmie Foxx (Golden Bear) - 123 total points
3. Johnny Mize (b-ball-lunachik) - 102 total points
4. Hank Greenberg (Throwback) - 90 total points
5. Willie McCovey (Yogi#8Fan) - 87 total points
6. Eddie Murray (hmrsf) - 82 total points
7. Willie Stargell (redsox617) - 71 total points
8. Jeff Bagwell (Buzz Buzzard) - 54 total points
9. Rafael Palmeiro (Xanadu Dragon) - 50 total points
10. George Sisler (ChrisCary) - 49 total points
11. Bill Terry (Duque) - 36 total points
12. Will Clark (pjl7) - 29 total points
13. Keith Hernandez (Mexicani Blue) - 20 total points

So that means the updated rankings are:

t1. redsox617 - 30 points
b-ball-lunachik - 30 points
3. hmrsf - 24 points
4. Duque - 23 points
t5. ChrisCary - 22 points
Yogi#8Fan - 22 points
Golden Bear - 22 points
nyy26wc - 22 points
9. Xanadu Dragon - 20 points
10. Throwback - 19 points
11. Buzz Buzzard - 16 points
12. pjl7 - 13 points
13. Mexicani Blue - 10 points