PDA

View Full Version : Pitcher Similarity


KCBOOMER
06-30-2004, 04:43 PM
For whatever reason I was thinking about Bill James comment in one of his books about how similar Andre Thornton and John Mayberry careers were. I thinn he ended up saying that they were the two most similar batters he could find (I can't remember the qualifiers he used).

Anyway for grins I went looking for similar pitchers with the only caveat that they have pitched 100 innings. I found Morris Amole and Pat Carney who have a similarity score of .995. I even calculated out their score and I got .997 (I don't know what I did wrong).

Amole was a LH starter for tge Baltimore Orioles (1897)and Washington Senators (1898) of the NL. In 18 games he posted a 4-10 record with 12 starts and a 4.75 era. Carney was a LH starter for the Boston Braves (1902-1904) of the NL. In 16 games he posted a 4-10 record with 12 starts and a 4.69 era.

Even more amazing was that both of these guys were nicknamed "Doc"!

Can you find any pitchers who are more similar??

Crash Course
06-30-2004, 08:53 PM
Patsy Tebeau and Stan Musial?

KCBOOMER
07-01-2004, 12:14 PM
Patsy Tebeau and Stan Musial?


Stan and Patsy are a little shy of the 100 IP criteria.

Crash Course
07-01-2004, 12:16 PM
Ah, arbitrary threshold requirements. ;)

KCBOOMER
07-01-2004, 12:23 PM
Ah, arbitrary threshold requirements. ;)


Yeah, but at least it is Bill James setting the threshold.