- James Lee "Kitty" Kaat
- Roger Eugene Maris
- John Scott "Jack" Morris
- Mark David McGwire "Big Mac"
- Anthony Keith Gwynn
- John Joseph McGraw "Mugsy" "Little Napoleon"
- Barry Louis Larkin
- Henry Louis Gehrig "The Iron Horse"
- Dorrel Norman Elvert "Whitey" Herzog
- Stanley Frank Musial "Stan the Man"
- Christopher "Christy" Mathewson
- Donald Arthur Mattingly
- Dale Bryan Murphy
- Joe Leonard Morgan
- Richard Michael "Goose" Gossage
- Adrian "Addie" Joss
- Henry Emmett "Heinie" Manush
- Leon Allen "Goose" Goslin
- Tully Frederick "Topsy" Hartsel
- Eddie Clarence Murray
- John Robert Mize "The Big Cat"
- Albert William Kaline
- Paul Leo Molitor "The Igniter"
- Frank Oliver Howard "Hondo" "The Capital Punisher"
- Bobby Ray Murcer
- Pack Robert Gibson
- Theodore Bernard Kluszewski "Big Klu"
- Keith Hernandez "Mex"
- Joseph James Kelley
- Juan Antonio Marichal "The Dominican Dandy"
- Gilbert Raymond Hodges
- Melvin Leroy "Chief" Harder
- Willie Howard Mays "The Say Hey Kid"
- Henry Benjamin Greenberg
- Rogers Hornsby "Rajah"
- Montford Merrill Irvin
- Michael Joseph Griffin
- Joseph Michael Medwick "Ducky" "Muscles"
- Mickey Charles Mantle
- Robert Granville Lemon
- Napoleon "Nap" Lajoie
- Sherwood Robert "Sherry" Magee
- William Robert "Sliding Billy" Hamilton
- Harry Bartholomew Hooper
- Kent Allen Hrbek
- John Henry "Pop" Lloyd
- Walter Fenner "Buck" Leonard
- Vernon Louis "Lefty" Gomez "Goofy"
- Robert Lee Johnson "Indian Bob"
- Theodore Amar "Ted" Lyons
- Walter Perry Johnson "The Big Train"
- Joseph Jefferson Jackson "Shoeless Joe"
- Gregory Michael Luzinski "The Bull"
- Ralph McPherran Kiner
- Anthony Michael Lazzeri "Poosh 'Em Up"
- Harmon Clayton "Killer" Killebrew
- Carl Owen Hubbell "King Karl" "The Meal Ticket"
- Reginald Martinez Jackson "Mr. October"
- Paul A. Hines
- Harry Edwin Heilmann "Slug"
- Charles Leo "Gabby" Hartnett
- Joshua Gibson
- Timothy John Keefe "Sir Timothy"
- Bill "Mad Dog" Madlock
- Robert Anthony Grich
- William Henry Keeler "Wee Willie"
- Michael Joseph "King" Kelly
- Charles Leonard Gehringer
- Robert Moses "Lefty" Grove
- Willie Lee "Stretch" McCovey
- Thomas Edward John "T.J."