- John Franklin "Home Run" Baker
- John Joseph McGraw "Mugsy" "Little Napoleon"
- Christopher "Christy" Mathewson
- Adrian "Addie" Joss
- Mordecai Peter Centennial "Three Finger" Brown
- George Edward "Rube" Waddell
- Tully Frederick "Topsy" Hartsel
- Edward Augustine Walsh "Big Ed"
- Samuel James Tilden Sheckard
- Smokey Joe Wood
- Edward Stewart Plank "Gettysburg Eddie"
- Edward Trowbridge Collins Sr.
- Grover Cleveland "Pete" Alexander
- Napoleon "Nap" Lajoie
- Sherwood Robert "Sherry" Magee
- Elmer Harrison Flick
- Harry Bartholomew Hooper
- Robert Hayes Veach
- Tristram E. Speaker "The Grey Eagle"
- Fred Clifford "Cap" Clarke
- Lawrence Joseph Doyle "Laughing Larry"
- John Peter "Honus" Wagner "The Flying Dutchman"
- Zachary Davis Wheat "Buck"
- Walter Perry Johnson "The Big Train"
- Joseph Jefferson Jackson "Shoeless Joe"
- Tyrus Raymond Cobb "The Georgia Peach"
- Clifford Byren "Gavvy" Cravath "Cactus"
- William Henry Keeler "Wee Willie"
- Samuel Earl Crawford "Wahoo Sam"